Review: Doctor Who – 2×3 – School Reunion

Cos I know you’re all dying to read it, my review of Saturday’s Doctor Who episode School Reunion is online at Off The Telly. For those that don’t want to make it that far, it’s below the fold as well.

Rose and Sarah JaneThroughout the land, grown men are crying. This isn’t because of some major sporting event, the death of a cherished footballer or because the Queen is 80. It’s because of the sacrifice made by a robot dog and the return of Sarah Jane Smith to Doctor Who.

If there was one episode fanboys of old were looking forward to in the latest series of the BBC’s top-rated drama, it was School Reunion. Forget the return of the Cybermen. Forget the return of Graeme Harper, the best director the show has even seen. What everyone wanted to see was how everyone’s favourite Doctor Who companions from the ’70s would fare in the new series, and how reverently they’d be treated. With all those expectations loaded onto its back, it’s amazing that School Reunion just about did the job expected of it and with more depth than anyone could have expected.

As with all post-Buffy Who, there was an A-plot and a B-plot to School Reunion. The surprise is that the A-plot, normally reserved for the poorly CGI-ed monster of the week, was handed over to the Doctor and his companions’ emotional tussling.

Instead, it was the B-plot that had to deal with the shape-changing, flying bat things that wanted to rule the universe by solving an equation, a plot lifted either from modern particle physics’ attempts to develop a grand unified field theory or from some old Superman comics – it’s unclear which. To solve the equation, the bat things take over a school, install Anthony Stewart Head as the headmaster, then pump up the brainpower of the pupils by lacing their chips with an alien oil. So maybe not Superman but The Demon Headmaster then. Anyway, so far, so ridiculous.

Meanwhile, back in the adult A-plot, ace investigative reporter Sarah Jane Smith (Elisabeth Sladen) was unceremoniously dumped back on Earth after happy years of companionhood with that wanderer in time and space known as the Doctor. 30 years later, spotting spaceships in the sky near a school of apparent geniuses, she decides to investigate, towing along her parting gift from the Doctor, a broken-down robot dog called K9. Mid-investigation, she comes across a mysterious stranger who appears to have stored an old-fashioned blue police box in the school gym …

For a script written by one of the least fanboyish of the current crop of writers, School Reunion is staggering in its concessions to the old series. While long-time fans Russell T Davies, Mark Gatiss and Steven Moffat have been doing their level best to avoid all continuity references, self-confessed Doctor Who ignoramus Toby Whithouse manages to sneak in references to just about every bit of K9 and Sarah Jane trivia imaginable. It’s a gamble, given how few of the current audience would have had even the faintest idea about who Sarah Jane and K9 were before the episode, but the script manages to explain everything necessary for the neophyte to cope with the backstory. It helps, of course, that the Beeb has been priming every well-behaved middle class kid with the necessary knowledge through guest appearances by Elisabeth Sladen and K9 on Blue Peter.

The meeting of old and new companions gives a chance for their stories and the Doctor’s to be explored, resulting in a surprisingly melancholy script. Nothing is given enormous depth, because there are bat-things to fight and only 45 minutes to do it in, but the plights of Rose and Sarah Jane, women who both travelled with a man who never ages, get examined in a way that’s never really been dealt with on the show before. The younger companion realises she’s not the first and probably won’t be the last woman who will ever share a TARDIS with the Doctor; the older companion realises that while she may have been special to the Doctor once, he’s moved on and barely mentions her.

This musing on the Doctor’s need for an endless stream of female companions, all of whom eventually must grow old and die, also gives David Tennant a chance to show his acting range in areas other than Prozac-quality cheeriness and anger. As if he hasn’t already done so in all his previous episodes, once again he effortlessly proves he’s a far better actor than the previous Doctor Who messiah, Christopher Eccleston.

Of the rest of cast and characters, Anthony Stewart Head is mostly wasted and bar a couple of homoerotic interactions with Tennant, is only really given opportunities to chew the scenery instead. Noel Clarke manages to get a handle on this “acting” thing at last and finally gets full TARDIS privileges. K9, complete with his original voice care of John Leeson, is used mostly as an object of fun; but it’s the “shooty dog thing” that eventually saves the day with a noble act of self-sacrifice that only the most heartless of viewers would have been unmoved by.

As Sarah Jane and the renovated K9 mark IV head off into the sunset again, finally having got the goodbyes they both deserved, a new generation of kids has been taught the nature of loss, death, age and mortality. It’s a brave children’s show that can do that. True, the plotting and effects are as ropey as last series, but the production team seem to have worked out the right balance between humour and gravitas, escapism and realism, sentimentality and banality.

Shed your tears for old Who because new Who is here and has finally found its way.

  • Neat review. I often feel I’m in a weird position in relation to the new series of Who. I’ve probably got a bit more knowledge of the previous incarnations of Doctor Who than most new fans (sadly a factor of age more than anything!), but I would never claim to be a full-on cite all the episodes fangirl. On that point, I suspect that David Tennant would have to teach me all he knows… sigh…
    (…Sorry. I’m back.)
    Certainly that prior knowledge is enough to spot the problems and difficulties created in the new format. But, lacking that emotional investment and knowledge of the full-on fan, I am also able to recognise how the new series is so much better than we could have hoped for. And it has been so breath-takingly enjoyable.
    Still, fab review as I say. Just seeing SJS and K9 was enough to make my heart jump with joy; that they were used so well was simply thrilling.

  • Why thank you kindly for your nice words!
    Citing every episode is surprisingly hard, even for former fanboys like me. I used to be able to make a stab at it, although not a very good, but these days, the thought processes are all a bit too faded. I tried to remember all the Jon Pertwee stories Lis Sladen had been in and it ended up going something like this:
    “The Time Warrior. Definitely The Time Warrior because that’s the one that introduced her and I remember Jon Pertwee referring to her as a ‘young girl’ in it, which raised some eyebrows. Then… Erm, Monster of Peladon cos that was on Doctor Who Confidential last night. Or maybe it was Curse of Peladon: which one’s which – one’s a sequel to the other? Erm. Daleks? Was she in a Pertwee Dalek story? I think I saw a Spiridon in one of the clips. Except they were invisible so I couldn’t have. So maybe it was something else. But possible Death to the Daleks. Or was it Planet of the Daleks? Wasn’t Planet of the Daleks the last six parts of a double-header with Frontier in Space? But that had the Master in and Roger Delgado was dead so couldn’t appear in season 12 which is why Jon Pertwee left. So it couldn’t have been Planet of the Daleks. Oh dear. So what one was it then? I give up.
    “Anyway. Planet of the Spiders was the last Pertwee story so she was in that. Ooh. Dinosaurs. She mentioned dinosaurs in ‘School Reunion’ so definitely ‘Invasion of the Dinosaurs’ then…”
    And that’s the best I can do these days. Which is probably a good thing actually, since that level of recollection is still worrying enough.

  • Great review. I’ve been watching Doctor Who going back to the Troughton era, and I think there’s a kind of infectious exuberance to the current incarnation that has something of the Golden Age about it. I’d like to see some longer storylines, though.
    God knows, there have been enough excellent episodes of The X Files and Buffy to prove that it can be done in 45 minutes, but I miss the cliffhangers. The success of Lost shows that cliffhangers still have their place, and I’d like to see the energy and exuberance of the current team applied to outrageous use of the cliffhanger in the same way Alias always has.

  • Ta again. Actually DW has 5 minutes longer than The X Files and Buffy since they only clocked in at 40 minutes each, thanks to the injection of an extra ad break to US TV schedules in the late 80s/early 90s (I think). Strange how DW still feels rushed in comparison. I miss the drawn out stories more than the cliffhangers, but I’m not sure how well the cliffhangers work in the age of “Next Episode”.
    As for the exuberance of the Doctor, I think he actually harks back to the 8th Doctor quite a bit. Although he doesn’t quite have the Peter Pan-ish qualities of Paul McGann’s Doctor, they’re pretty similar in a lot of ways, right down to their romanticism, familiarity with 21st century culture and slang and so on.
    Worryingly, I’ve checked the BBC’s Doctor Who episode guide (worrying in itself) and I got all those Pertwee episodes right. It was season 11 and they were in the wrong order (plus it was Monster of Peladon and Death to the Daleks – that was an Exilon I spotted), but all the same.
    It’s a bugger though. How come I can remember that rubbish but I can’t remember most of my 20s?

  • I’m becoming a fangirl. I surpressed it for a while but I see I’m among likeminded friends… 😉 Great review.


    I remember the FIRST episode – I was at a party and I was five! I was the only one who wasn’t scared but was scared of episodes shown later. I thought the k9 episode was brilliant and very moving. David Tennant is wonderful.

  • Pingback: The Medium is Not Enough TV blog()

  • Pingback: The Medium is Not Enough TV blog()

  • Pingback: The Medium is Not Enough TV blog()

  • Pingback: The Medium is Not Enough TV blog()