US TV

Review: Dominion 1×1 (SyFy)


In the US: Thursdays, 9/8c, SyFy

It used to be that there was a reason for adapting movies into TV series. Not necessarily a good one, but there was a reason: people liked the movie so why not cash in on that? It always helped if it was a good movie, because that tricky difficult bit – coming up with a proven good idea and a source material that people would enjoy – was already out the way.

So I’m at an absolute loss to understand Dominion. SyFy might as well have beamed onto our screens a picture of a six-legged cat attacking Luke Goss from Bros with a packet of instant custard and a small porcelain statue of the Ayatollah Khomeini and that still would have made more sense than Dominion.

Remember the 2010 movie Legion, in which Paul Bettany was involved in a war on Earth among the angels after God absconds? Liar. Of course you don’t. Even if you had seen it, your brain would have tried to purge the whole unpleasant experience from your memory. You’re probably just thinking of season five of Supernatural. Easy mistake to make.

Fact: There are literally no fans of Legion. None whatsoever. Science has proven this.

But supposing you were bitten by a rabid bat and in your fevered state, your memory became clear, you suddenly remembered Legion and you decided to make a TV version of it. Wouldn’t you want to at least call it Legion or maybe have something in common with the original movie?

Not so with SyFy. Dominion it is and the whole show is set decades after that war between the angels. Humanity is now living in semi-feudal socities sealed off inside gated cities, while humans possessed by lower angels, particularly those in league with the evil archangel Gabriel (cough, cough, The Prophecy, cough, cough), try to assail those cities and infiltrate them. 

Meanwhile, there’s a prophecy of a saviour child who will come to end the stalemate and the war (cough, cough… oh, done this already). Except no one’s quite sure where the good archangel Michael hid him.

Throw in something about nuclear reactors, Anthony Head from Buffy and Alan Dale from Neighbours as human leaders pairing their offspring off with each other, missing dads with angelic script on their bodies, a bit of Battlestar Galactica, a bit of Mad Max, an angelic orgy, some sword fights, some gun fights, some anti-aircraft batteries, some Las Vegas cage-fighting and a cast of British, Australian and South African actors faking US accents for no good reason and without much success and you have just the first two episodes of Dominion – a candidate for the title of ‘worst TV programme ever made’.

Here’s a trailer.

Continue reading “Review: Dominion 1×1 (SyFy)”

The BarrometerA Barrometer rating of 3

Third-episode verdict: Crossbones (NBC)

In the US: Fridays, 10/9c, NBC

Were Crossbones, Neil Cross’s (Luther) moderately ahistorical adaptation of the story of famous pirate Blackbeard, happily ensconced in the Saturday teatime slot, it would probably be the best Saturday teatime adventure fare for a long, long time. While the show plays more than a little bit fast and loose with history, has a somewhat Pirates of the Caribbean attitude towards a bunch of thieves, rapists, kidnappers and murderers, and forsakes plausibility and great acting in favour of ghostly visions and John Malkovich with spikes in his head and the strangest accent you ever did hear coming from his mouth, the show is at least fun (unlike Black Sails), remembers in the second half of every episode to have some swashbuckling, looks good and is a bit smarter than you might have been expecting.

Except this is a 10/9c show. It’s aimed at adults. And for that, it’s a little too silly. Yet it doesn’t truly realise it. Except for Malkovich of course.

Since its first episode, the show has moved on from being Heart of Darkness with pirates and has in fact pretty much forgotten why it ever sent Richard Coyle to try to kill the dread pirate Malkovich. Instead, it’s seen Coyle become an uneasy ally with Malkovich, who is part hero, part psychopath, part politician, all rolled up in a man who seems surprised that he’s being paid so much money to play at pirates in Puerto Rico.

Episode two saw Spanish submarines and, strangely enough, Malkovich’s attempts to impose an Athenian-style democracy on a nation of pirates, as well as the continuing romance between Coyle and Claire Foy’s feisty aristocrat-cum-quartermistress. Episode three gave us a slightly more pedestrian affair, with Coyle and Malkovich having to rescue Foy from the clutches of Coyle’s employer (Julian Sands being as Julian Sands as it’s possible to be). Supposedly, this was enabled through a cunning plan of Coyle’s but since it required Sands to act like he’d been dropped on his head as a baby, there’s apparently quite a low bar to pirate cunning.

It’s all jolly good fun – at least, in the second half of each episode when the show stops trying to be an actual drama, filled with not especially great attempts at character development and chessboard-like plotting, and decides to give us lots of swordfights and ships firing cannons at each other. It’s at its best when Cross bring Coyle and Malkovich together to share some decidedly above-average and knowing dialogue, at its worst whenever it tries to add depth to any of the hammier supporting characters or deal with anyone female. Historical purists will have a field day, but anyone who enjoys a Saturday tea time romp with period ships, doesn’t mind Britain’s legitimate attempts to stamp out criminality being portrayed as pure evil and wants to see how much latitude Cross and co give Malkovich will have a great 50% of the time.

Barrometer rating: 3
Rob’s prediction: Will probably make it to the end of the season and might even make it to two

News: Turn to return, Showtime’s Girlfriends, an Intruders trailer + more

Internet TV

New UK TV shows

US TV

US TV casting

New US TV shows

New US TV show casting

  • Carl Lumbly joins A&E’s The Returned remake
  • PJ Byrne joins HBO’s Martin Scorsese rock and roll pilot

News: Freema Agyeman is in Sense8, Joanna Page joins Knifeman, Rosario Dawson is a Daredevil + more

Doctor Who

  • Sequel to The Five(ish) Doctors planned

Film

Film casting

Trailers

  • Trailer for The Drop with Tom Hardy, Noomi Rapace and James Gandolfini
  • Trailer for Love is Strange with John Lithgow and Alfred Molina

Theatre

  • Tamsin Greig to star in Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown adaptation

Australian TV

Internet TV

UK TV

New UK TV shows

  • BBC3 announces nine Comedy Feed pilots
  • Trailer for BBC1’s Common

US TV

US TV show casting

New US TV shows

New US TV show casting

What have you been watching? Including Murder In the First, Continuum, Suits, Old School and Undateable

It’s “What have you been watching?”, my chance to tell you what movies and TV I’ve been watching recently that I haven’t already reviewed and your chance to recommend things to everyone else (and me) in case I’ve missed them.

The usual “TMINE recommends” page features links to reviews of all the shows I’ve ever recommended, and there’s also the Reviews A-Z, for when you want to check more or less anything I’ve reviewed ever. And if you want to know when any of these shows are on in your area, there’s Locate TV – they’ll even email you a weekly schedule.

A slightly slower week this week, with only one new show unveiled – SyFy’s Dominion. Hopefully, I’ll be reviewing that later today, but so far it looks like possibly the worst TV show ever made. Although obviously The Starlost still provides strong competition there.

After the jump,  a round-up of the regulars, with reviews of 24, Continuum, Enlisted, Game of Thrones, Murder In The First, Old School, Penny Dreadful, Suits and Undateable.

Continue reading “What have you been watching? Including Murder In the First, Continuum, Suits, Old School and Undateable”