TV reviews

A complete archive of The Medium is Not Enough’s reviews of TV programmes since 2005

UK TV

Review: Line of Duty (BBC2) 1×1

2 July 2012 Rob Buckley 90 Comments

In the Line of Duty

In the UK: Tuesdays, 9pm, BBC2. Available on the iPlayer

Well, if I’m going to start watching UK dramas again, I guess BBC2 – and a drama written by Jed Mercurio and starring the wonderful Lennie James (from Jericho et al), no less – is a good place to start. Line of Duty is a police complaints procedural that looks at an investigation into a top cop’s apparently spotless, amazing record to see how he manages it. Along the way, we get to see how the Met now deals with complaints – both officially and unofficially – while watching the police investigating themselves in a (to use a cliché) game of cat and mouse.

And while it’s actually pretty good, there’s a faint whim of the ridiculous throughout, to the extent you’re sometimes not sure whether it’s being serious, being deliberately funny or is simply having trouble taking itself seriously.

Here’s a trailer followed by the first four minutes or so. You’ll see what I mean about not knowing whether it’s supposed to be ridiculous or not from the the second video.

Continue reading “Review: Line of Duty (BBC2) 1×1”

US TV

Review: Anger Management (FX) 1×1-1×2

2 July 2012 Rob Buckley Post a comment

Anger Management

In the US: Thursdays, 9.30pm, FX
In the UK: Not yet acquired.

So how do you want to be remembered when you die? Do you want to go out with a bang or do you want to fade away?

Charlie Sheen seemed dead certain to be going for option a. After a catastrophic public meltdown that saw him chucked off Two And A Half Men, one of the US’s top-rated comedy shows, he seemed to be going pellmell towards even further collapse. And then…

…he signed up for Anger Management, an FX sitcom. Well, surely that was going to be like petrol to a forest fire – an even greater disaster in the making.

Except not. Anger Management is a fairly traditional sitcom in which Charlie Sheen plays Charlie, a former baseball player turned anger management therapist who has some – but not much – difficulty dealing with his patients, another therapist (Selma Blair) who is also his best friend with benefits, his ex-wife and his daughter, as well as dating in general.

And while there are a couple of meta-moments about his firing from Two And A Half Men at the beginning of the first episode and while in many ways this is the same womanising Charlie of that sitcom, this is not the Charlie Sheen you might have been expecting. This is a Charlie Sheen who can talk coherently, intelligently, sensitively about issues and resolve them like an intelligent adult.

Boy is it dull, even if FX is trailing it as something of train wreck. It seems Charlie Sheen went with option b.

Continue reading “Review: Anger Management (FX) 1×1-1×2”

US TV

Review: The Newsroom (HBO) 1×1

26 June 2012 Rob Buckley 15 Comments

 

In the US: Sundays, 10pm, HBO
In the UK: Acquired by Sky Atlantic. Will air starting July 10

I guess it was only a matter of time before Aaron Sorkin got around to creating The Newsroom. You could probably have proved it with Venn diagrams or something.

Sorkin does, of course, love two things above all others: politics and TV shows about TV shows. On the politics side, The West Wing looked at the undeniable vital national importance of decent politics and politicians, but Sorkin also wrote the Guantanamo-tastic A Few Good Men. As far as TV shows about TV shows go, he’s had a patchier track record: Studio 60 On The Sunset Strip, which looked at the vital national importance of live comedy sketch shows, was a flop, as was Sports Night, which looked at the vital national importance of TV sports shows. 

So I guess it was inevitable that Sorkin would develop a TV show that incorporated into its storylines not just politics but also a TV show about politics. Thus we have The Newsroom, almost a ‘Greatest Sorkin Hits’ collection of things you’ll have seen and loved in previous Sorkin productions: politics; a TV show with behind-the-scenes relationship problems for the production team; ditzy women; failing men; witty banter; talking and walking; beautifully written, fact-heavy sermons; ethnic minority assistants; people doing the right thing; people doing jobs to the best of their abilities; and exhortions about how much better America could be if only all its citizens were well educated.

In this show, of course, we also get journalism and long speeches about how important it is. And as with much of The Newsroom, although you may have seen something similar on Studio 60 et al, here it just about works, because journalism is plausibly of vital national importance – unlike live comedy sketch shows. It’s not quite The West Wing, either in the quality of the cast, which includes Jeff Daniels, Emily Mortimer, Olivia Munn, Sam Waterston, Dev Patel and Jane Fonda, or in the power of its execution, but it’s certainly a pretty good start – assuming you like Sorkin.

Here’s a trailer or two and if you’re in the US, you can watch the whole of the first episode.

Continue reading “Review: The Newsroom (HBO) 1×1”

What did you watch last fortnight? Including Dallas, Wilfred, Burn Notice and Freakanomics

25 June 2012 Rob Buckley 9 Comments

It’s “What did you watch last fortnight?”, my chance to tell you what I watched last fortnight that I haven’t already reviewed and your chance to recommend things to everyone else (and me) in case I’ve missed them.

The usual recommendations from the first-run shows are: Continuum, The Daily Show and Prisoners of War. Hunt them down. Suits is back and despite the change in showrunner, is still aces so that’s back on the must-see list, and Hit and Miss has been good enough that I’m adding that to the list as well.

Here’s a few thoughts on what else I’ve been watching, though:

  • Burn Notice: Okay, I’m weak and I’ve started watching it again. To be fair, the showrunners did promise that they had basically run out of stories to tell with the old formula and have sworn to mix it up a bit this season, which they have (spoilers): Fiona’s in jail and Michael’s properly working for the CIA again There are still traces of the formula in that Michael is still having to deal with problem of the week (aka “bad character actor of the week”), but it is different, thankfully. Still lacking a certain pizzazz with everyone seemingly just a little bit tired and going through the motions, but okay as a way to pass the summer, I guess.
  • Wilfred: Decided to give this one a try again and although it’s fun, it’s still a very weird, very dark exercise in comedy. Some interesting cameos, including Robin Williams, and Allison Mack from Smallville is now part of the cast. I might watch next week’s just to see how they’re going to play out the rest of the season, now that Elijah Wood is confirmed as a complete mental.
  • Dallas: Yes, Dallas is back. Some of the old cast are back, too, including Bobby, JR and Sue Ellen, with a couple of cameos. It’s about as plausible as the original series, but suffers from one serious problem: the youngsters. A lot of the show mirrors the original show by having a rivalry between two relatives, this time JR Jr and Bobby’s son, plus their respective wives and girlfriends, as well as a few others. And they all have the charisma of puddles, compared to the original cast. It’s quite embarrassing. So you spend your whole time watching it, hoping the youngsters will get out of the way so you can see Larry Hagman being magnificent. So I gave up after the first episode.
  • Playhouse Presents: Quite an uneven series of plays, with one obvious standout: The Snipist, starring Dougie Henshall and directed by Matthew Holness, which was really rather good, harking back to golden-age miserable delights like The Mad Death. Unfortunately, despite the casts and writers of the other plays, which included the likes of Sandi Toksvig and Jeremy Dyson, that was about it, each play starting out promising but tailing off by the end with no real conclusions or resolutions. Hopefully, they’ll learn to be a little bit more didactic next series.

And in movies:

  • Freakanomics: If you’ve read the book, you’ll have seen most of this – exercises in how economics and mathematics can tell you things about the way the world works. Each segment is directed by someone different and Morgan Spurlock’s ‘names’ segment is probably the most entertaining, while the segment looking at cheating in sumo wrestling is probably the most interesting, not least because it actually builds on the book to show you the book’s effect and does some investigative journalism all of its own. Fun, but not must-see.

“What did you watch this week?” is your chance to recommend to friends and fellow blog readers the TV and films that they might be missing or should avoid – and for me to do mini-reviews of everything I’ve watched. Since we live in the fabulous world of Internet catch-up services like the iPlayer and Hulu, why not tell your fellow readers what you’ve seen so they can see the good stuff they might have missed?

The CarusometerA Carusometer rating of 3

Third-episode verdict: Longmire (A&E)

19 June 2012 Rob Buckley Post a comment

In the US: Sundays, 10/9c, A&E

So time to pass a verdict on A&E’s new show, modern western Longmire. Not much has changed since the first episode, in which craggy Robert Taylor went around investigating crimes in Wyoming, aided by his traditional, conservative values, while pesky women, youngsters and Native Americans (there are no gay people in Wyoming) tried their best to help or interfere, but proved to be no match for his superior wit and inherent white male superiority.

The subsequent two episodes have more of less followed this exact same formula, albeit with fewer thrills and with less depth. Everything’s about Taylor or about making Taylor look good, while Katee Sackhoff and company get little by way of plot, characterisation or anything else.

However, it is a well made show, thoughtful, mostly well acted, beautiful to look at, and it does have moments of poignancy. It’s also a refreshing change to most urban dramas, looking at rural issues that don’t often appear in crime dramas, although episode three does have the mob intruding. Taylor’s character is sympathetic, even if he’s simultaneously an ornery, uncommunicative man of the land, and Sackhoff is good in more or less everything she’s in.

Sometimes engrossing, different but nothing spectacular.

Carusometer rating: 3
Rob’s prediction: If The Glades can survive for four seasons on A&E, this will probably last at least a couple.