Thursday’s Cucumber news

Film

British TV

US TV

Film

Question of the week: is it okay for things to be shit?

Transformers 3

This was actually inspired by @snarkandfury: ‘I’m so tired of the “it’s only a kids film/TV show/property based on an 80s toy it’s supposed to be shit” defence. It’s never OK to be shit’ who I think was inspired by a recent discussion on this ‘ere blog.

So simple question/set of questions:

Is it okay for something to not have any artistic merit whatsoever and to be shit, provided enough people like it? Does artistic merit actually stop something from being as entertaining as something more visceral? Or is merely being enjoyed by people at a visceral level actually an artistic merit? And does all that get cancelled out and become null and void if it turns out that not only is something completely shit, it’s also racist, sexist and homophobic?

Answers below or on your own blog, please

Wednesday’s “Gods behaving awesomely” news

Film

Books

British TV

US TV

Film

Michael Bay reuses footage from The Island in Transformers 3

I haven’t watched Transformers 3, on the general grounds that I saw Transformers and Transformers 2 was apparently even more awful. Plus Mark Kermode gave a whole host of good reasons why I wouldn’t want to, such as it being racist, sexist and homophobic, as well as astonishingly stupid.

I have, however, watched The Island, with the impossibly lovely and random Scarlett Johansson, which had a very good first half and an impossibly bad, very stupid Michael Bay second half.

But Bay says he learnt from The Island that what the kids of today wanted wasn’t the thoughtful, interesting first half but the explosions-laden second half.

So, apparently, the world is doomed because the next generation is composed of morons. Oh well.

Anyway, so convinced of this does Michael Bay appear to have become that in Transformers 3, he’s actually gone and reused footage from The Island. Because you know, when you have a reported $250 million budget, you really have to scrimp, save and cut corners to make ends meet. How bizarre.

Has anyone else noticed, incidentally, that Rosie Huntington-Whiteley doesn’t get a single line of dialogue in any of the Transformers 3 trailers. That’s something of a warning about her acting talents, I think.

Tuesday’s frozen pants news

Commercials

Film

Audio plays

British TV

US TV