Preview: Second Chance 1×1 (US: Fox)

A Frankenstein's monster of other programmes


In the US: Wednesdays, 9/8c, Fox. Starts January 13
In the UK: Not yet acquired

What’s in a name, you might ask. Quite a lot, it seems, in the case of Second Chance, given the contortions it’s gone through in its brief life.

The show stars Robert Kazinsky (Dream Team, EastEnders, Pacific Rim) and Philip Michael Hall (The Loop) as Jimmy Pritchard, a retired disgraced sheriff who consorts with prostitutes and has a ‘problematic’ relationship with his FBI son widower Tim DeKay (White Collar) and granddaughter Ciara Bravo (Red Band Society).

You might have noticed that I said that both Hall and Kazinsky play Jimmy Pritchard. For a change, that’s not a grammatical mistake on my part. You see, there’s a brilliant pair of rich twins (Dilshad Vadsaria from Greek and Adhir Kalyan from Rules of Engagement). Vadsaria is dying of a rare form of cancer and so Kalyan invents a process that could save her, provided they find someone genetically compatible and a bit dead. Because Kalyan can bring the right person back from the dead and in considerably improved condition – as a better version of themselves, stronger, faster and even younger. And then they can milk him for his curative white blood cells.

When the 70-something Hall finds DeKay’s office being broken into, the perps end up throwing him off a bridge. Kalyan brings him back as Kazinsky, who’s offered not just a second chance at stopping the perps, but also doing good and perhaps even improving his relationship with his family.

Now, originally, this was called The Frankenstein Code. Whether it’s because it had almost nothing to do with Mary Shelley’s original book or whether it was because ITV had The Frankenstein Chronicles coming out at roughly the same time, I don’t know. But the show soon got renamed Looking Glass – the name of Vadsaria and Kalyan’s social media company – and the only vestige of the original name is now Vadsaria’s name, ‘Mary Godwin’ (Godwin being Shelley’s maiden name). Apparently, though, Looking Glass was too cryptic and perhaps even too suggestive of Lewis Carroll, because the show was soon renamed Second Chance, which at least is a bit closer to what the show’s about.

However, I wonder how much of this name-changing is to distract us all from the fact that Second Chance is basically Now and Again, in which Eric Close plays a genetically perfect reincarnation of the dead John Goodman who’s created to solve crimes and do espionage, but spends all his time wanting to fix things with his family, now he can’t be with them.

Second Chance has rather a lot in common with Now and Again – a similar plot, similar concerns, better when dealing with family matters than with cops and spies. It’s different enough that lawsuits probably won’t be flying, but similar enough that you’ll feel like you’re watching a rerun when you watch it.

It’s not without a few saving graces. The idea that youth is wasted on the youthful and the idea of a ‘do over’ are timelessly appealing. This also isn’t ‘single point’ sci-fi, with the twin’s ability to resurrect the dead coming ex nihilo and everything else remaining the same. Instead, it’s set in the near future, where everyone’s house has computer displays in the windows and a portable of army of UAVs is available when you need it. The show also channels ‘superbeing shows’ of the 70s and 80s, such as The Gemini Man and Northstar, by giving our hero a time limit each day before he has to be returned to a tank to stop his super-powerful new body rejecting his enhancements and dying permanently.

But it’s still not great. Hall’s a more interesting character than Kazinsky, just as Goodman was better than Close, inviting his frequent return, I suspect. DeKay is either studiously doing serious acting or has lost the will to live, knowing he’s always going to be playing the FBI straight man to someone more interesting – I can’t tell which. The rest of the cast aren’t great shakes and the cop plots are pretty perfunctory and solved with a couple of punches.

Nevertheless, there’s at least potential here and the chance for the show to grow in interesting directions, since there’s no obvious fixed format for it. Maybe he’ll go off solving crimes; maybe he’ll try to bond with his family; maybe he’ll be the subject of scientific research every week.

At best, it’ll probably be easy viewing on an unchallenging Monday. But that’s still better than pretty much any other recent Fox sci-fi show.




  • Andy Butcher

    They should use “still better than pretty much any other recent Fox sci-fi show” as an example on the Wikipedia page for 'damning with faint praise'. 😉

    Found this to be exceedingly average at best. Maybe it's just my imagination being sparked by all the name changes, but it also felt like a show that had been messed around with by network execs until it bore hardly any resemblance to the original pitch.

    As you say, it has Mondays going for it, so I might watch the next couple just in case it does that thing of becoming a different show in the second or third episode.