A Tuesday Doctor Who meme

I’ve not had much joy with these meme things, but I thought I’d give it another go. Today’s meme of fun, to be answered in your own blog or in the comments section, is quite a simple one and I reckon there are enough people here in the know to give it a go.

So here it is: what are you three favourite Doctor Who stories and why? You can have stories from the old series, new series, audio plays, movies, books, comics, stage plays, even fan fic. You don’t have to arrange them in any order (nor put down any other stories if you don’t want). You just need to name your top three.

To get things rolling, here are mine:

  1. Caves of Androzani: It’s just so bleak! With the exception of two characters, everyone dies; even the Doctor ‘dies’. There are those marvellous, fourth-wall breaking asides to the audience by Morgus.
  2. Kinda: One of the only attempts to do proper literary-style sci-fi. Full of Buddhist metaphors, it does suffer a bit from cheapo production values and the inflatable snake. But it’s a cracker all the same. It was either this or the sequel Snakedance anyway.
  3. Genesis of the Daleks: Well, it had to be, didn’t it? Again, bleak as bleak can be, but it was Tombo at his finest, Davros at his most nuanced and the Daleks, surprisingly, at their scariest.

I toyed with Ark In Space (evil alien wasp things lay their eggs inside human beings), Deadly Assassin (the Doctor’s first proper return to Gallifrey) and The Five Doctors (it’s fun) but those were the winners.

Who wants to be first with the follow-ups? Anyone? Bueller?

UPDATE: I’m actually reconsidering Genesis of the Daleks in favour of Ambassadors of Death: it’s adult, gritty, and intelligent thanks to a corker of a script from David Whitaker. Pertwee is on excellent form, Liz Shaw has great fun taunting bad guys (my faves: “It’s so simple even you could understand it” and “Don’t worry, I won’t hurt you”) and there’s some fantastic direction, with some particularly well composed shots that you just wouldn’t have expected from the Beeb of the time. Plus you have to appreciate a composer of incidental music, who when faced with an action scene, doesn’t go for the obvious but goes for the flute solo instead. Marvellous.

Borat movie – first four minutes

Borat – Sacha Baron Cohen’s other character – is somewhat of an acquired taste. Either you’ll love him or hate him. He’s got a new movie coming out soon, Borat: Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan, and here are the first four minutes to help you make up your mind (whether you love him or hate him).

The Persuaders! movie gets a writer

‘Classic’ ITC series The Persuaders! is being turned into a movie. So far, it looks like Ben Stiller and Steve Coogan are going to play Danny Wilder and Lord Brett Sinclair, played by Tony Curtis and Roger Moore in the original. Now they’ve found a writer, David Dorfman, to write the screenplay. He was responsible for Anger Management, so react to that news how you want.

Reviews for Torchwood, Robin Hood, et al are in

Reviews of various programmes that I’ve been blogging about recently (bar Prime Suspect, which I’ll be blogging about once I’ve watched the second episode).

Torchwood, BBC3

“Unless it improves quickly, even they [the fans] might start to notice that this really isn’t Doctor Who for adults, as promised. Instead, it’s Doctor Who with added sex and swearing – which isn’t the same thing at all.”

James Walton, The Daily Telegraph

Torchwood, BBC3

“This looks promising: it’s slick, quick and a tiny bit scary.”

Sam Wollaston, The Guardian

Simon Schama’s Power of Art, BBC2

“They’d spent some money on costumes and stick-on beards, but the sets were empty and the acting was of the declamatory sort.”

Phil Hogan, The Observer

Simon Schama’s Power of Art, BBC2

“There is just enough substance in the programme to leave you feeling spiritually nourished.”

Hermione Eyre, The Independent on Sunday

Simon Schama’s Power of Art, BBC2

“The point of these authored, visually clotted documentaries is really to be infomercials for instant coffee table tomes.”

AA Gill, The Sunday Times

Prime Suspect, ITV1

“Despite the occasional wobble along the way, both Tennison and the programme had remained true to their ideals by resisting the pressure to go out with a melodramatic bang.”

James Walton, The Daily Telegraph

Prime Suspect, ITV1

“The first episode of Prime Suspect was about as good as television ever gets.”

AA Gill, The Sunday Times

Lead Balloon, BBC4

“Lead Balloon is well worth watching. It is a delectable comedy of everyday embarrassment, and as such feels exquisitely British.”

Hermione Eyre, The Independent on Sunday

Robin Hood, BBC1

“Correction: in a review earlier this month, I may have implied that Robin Hood was quite good. Having now sat through three hours of dialogue as clunky as a 1970s seat belt, it’s perfectly clear that I couldn’t have been more wrong. Apologies all round.”

Sam Wollaston, The Guardian