In the US: Fridays, 9/8c, NBC
In the UK: Acquired by 5*. Will air early 2017
Grimdark is one of those words that can stop you taking an entire genre seriously. In this case, it's a mocking moniker for the prevalent idea that by making something dark and humourless, it's not only more adult, it's also better.
That's certainly been the approach of the producers of Emerald City, a beautifully directed but ultimately empty grimdark reimagining of The Wizard of Oz. It sees Dorothy a modern day Kansas nurse who gets whisked off by a tornado to the land of Oz, where she meets grimdark versions of familiar characters, ranging from the Munchkins (Icelandic speaking barbarians who paint themselves like they're in Braveheart) through the Scarecrow (murderous former soldier who's had his memories removed) to the Wizard of Oz (prostitute-visiting genocidal bully). The witches are there in varying degrees of drug-using, murderous, torturing depravity, too.
Oh so serious and important.
But grimdark. Tee hee.
Tell you what grimdark never manages to do: it never makes you care about a character, just their situation. And that's been consistent across all three episodes so far, with all manner of bad things happening, yet nothing ever making you care about the victims, beyond the fact they've been pushed to their doom by their gender-swapping childhood best friend or whatever miserable incident they've had to endure.
Other than the semi-decent cast assembled for the piece, what elevates the show from simple disgruntled teen's fan fiction to the point where it's almost watchable is the direction by Tarsem Singh, who makes the whole show genuinely beautiful to watch, something he's helped in considerably by the Spanish location shooting. Even while someone's emoting about some ancient prophecy concerning The Beast Beyond or dancing a ritual for dead witches, the viewer can simply drink in the mise-en-scène, admire a beautiful piece of Islamic architecture or Antoni Gaudí's Park Güell, and ignore the tedious dialogue.
Emerald City is imaginative and good to look at, but despite its best efforts, unlike The Wizard of Oz, it fails to make you care about the protagonists, antagonists or anyone else.
Barrometer rating: 3
TMINE's prediction: One season and one season only
- January 27, 2017: When's that show you mentioned starting again, TMINE? Including Greenleaf, Emerald City, Roots and MacGyver
The UK premiere dates for Greenleaf, Emerald City, Roots, MacGyver, I Love Dick and 13 Reasons Why