Categorised | Australian and New Zealand TV

Tags | None

Review: Secrets and Lies 1x1 (Network Ten/Channel 5)

Posted on March 5, 2014 | Post a comment | Bookmark and Share

Secrets and Lies (Australia)

In Australia: Thursdays, 9.30pm, Network Ten
In the UK: Acquired by Channel 5

If you ask me, this format thing is getting out of hand. Secrets and Lies is Australia’s latest piece of event TV – or at least Network Ten’s attempt to create a piece of event TV. In it, Brisbane family man Ben Gundelach (Martin Henderson best known for, of all things, The Ring) comes across the body of a dead child while running. When he reports it to the police, his whole world falls apart as first the cops, then the media then everyone else he knows begins to suspect that he killed the boy. Did Gundelach do it and if he didn’t, who did? Could it even be one of his neighbours?

It’s six episodes long, it has a companion mobile app (Zeebox), there’s social media channels and a web site dedicated to helping viewers solve the mystery – it’s a big thing. Or wants to be, anyway. Whether it is or not is debatable, given it got 403,000 viewers for its first episode and finished in fourth in its timeslot.

Yet ABC in the US committed to remaking the format even before the show had aired. They’ve just cast Ryan Phillippe and Juliette Lewis in the pilot.

This, I think, is jumping the gun. Because the show’s okay. But only okay.

The first episode treads a very ordinary path, in fact. There’s a little bit of the emotion of The Killing in there; there’s the usual tropes about the police, innocent man accused and so on. About the only extraordinary thing about it is how ordinary Gundelach’s character is. He’s just a house painter – a guy with regular kids and a rocky marriage who spends all his time trying to drum up business, promising to do the work he’s already promised to do, and larking around with his next door neighbour.

Can’t see Ryan Phillippe doing that myself, but let’s see how it pans out.

Now, whether later episodes will give us a mystery worth solving, since there have been no apparent clues as to motive, other suspects or even much by way of foul play at this stage, is something we’ll have to wait to discover. At the moment, although Henderson is a compelling lead, one contractually obliged to only wear a top 50% of the time, we’ve not yet got a compelling story that tells us anything more than ‘it’s crap being accused of a crime you didn’t commit’. The police are still menacing caricatures and his family are little more than human beings arranged around him to convey disappointment.

So is it worth a remake? Not yet. But I’ll stick with it for now…

Related entries

  • March 6, 2014: Review: The Red Road 1x1 (Sundance TV)
    A review of the first episode of Sundance TV’s The Red Road
  • March 18, 2014: Third-episode verdict: Secrets and Lies (Network Ten/Channel 5)
    A review of the first three episodes of Network Ten's Secrets and Lies
  • March 17, 2014: Third-episode verdict: The Red Road (Sundance TV)
    A review of the first three episodes of Sundance TV's The Red Road, starring Jason Momoa and Martin Henderson
  • March 6, 2014: What have you been watching? Including Community, 19-2, Arrow, Hannibal and The Doctor Blake Mysteries
    What I watched on TV in the week ending 6th March 2014
  • March 14, 2014: What have you been watching? Including Growing Up Fisher, Secrets and Lies, Red Road, Suits and Agents of SHIELD
    What I watched on TV in the week ending 14th March 2014
  • March 10, 2015: Review: Secrets and Lies (US) 1x1-1x3 (US: ABC)
    A review of the first three episodes of ABC’s remake of Ten’s Secrets and Lies
  • March 9, 2015: What have you been watching? Including Dig, Maximum Choppage, The Americans, Fortitude, 12 Monkeys and Vikings
    A review of the TV and films I watched in the week ending March 9 2015
  • April 26, 2017: Season review: Seven Types of Ambiguity (Australia: ABC)
    A review of ABC (Australia)'s Seven Types of Ambiguity

Allowable comments

You can leave just about any kind of comment you like. You can argue, suggest I am (or anyone else is) wrong, leaving general messages of love – anything. However, you absolutely can't leave messages that attack other commenters (or me), are simple variations of "your review sucks" or that are misogynistic, racist, homophobic, etc: your comment will either be edited or deleted and you'll be barred from leaving any further comments. We want to keep it civil here.

Spoilers

You can hide a spoiler by putting <spoiler> before it and </spoiler> after it. Hover over a spoiler to reveal it!

Featured Articles

The Bold Type

Journalism for people who can't read more than a Tweet