Categorised | Nostalgia corner

Lost Gems (?): Wonder Woman (2011)

Posted on July 28, 2011 | comments | Bookmark and Share

Adrienne Palicki as Wonder Woman

In the US: Never

So I'm going to out myself as a bit of a Wonder Woman fan. I love her in the comics (with the right authors such as George Perez, Gail Simone and Greg Rucka), we have the whole 1970s TV series on DVD, we have the animated movie on iTunes and lovely wife has a Wonder Woman mug to drink from. I even have a couple of Wonder Woman encyclopaedias on the shelves.

I know. Sad.

But I'll tell you for why. As well as Wonder Woman being one of the very few iconic and powerful female superheroes out there, the DC universe is such that while Superman is off fighting sci-fi enemies, Batman is fighting human grotesques and Captain Marvel is off beating up magical villains, Wonder Woman is the fourth iconic pillar: she's the mythological hero, fighting gods and monsters. Her stories are unique and she has a necessary, irreplaceable area of the comics world to call her own.

But there's still more to her: she is literally an emissary from the Greek gods, who are second to none in the DC universe (no Christian or any other monotheistic gods at the top of this pantheon), and they have imbued her with their powers to give their mortals a message: there's a better way to live than patriarchy.

In other words, despite what you may or may not think about her costume, she's just about the only feminist and indeed religious superhero out there and when she prays, her prayers are answered.

Wonder Woman's prayer is answered

Wonder Woman's TV and movie career is a little checkered. There was a dreadful 1967 pilot that tried to do for Wonder Woman what the Batman TV series did for the caped crusader - camp it up. Then Cathy Lee Crosby did a quite awful TV movie version that preserved most of the trappings of Wonder Woman, but robbed her of all her powers.

Lynda Carter had a much better time of things from 1976, with three seasons of The New Adventures of Wonder Woman. The first season, set as the original comic was during World War 2, wasn't bad and did a reasonably good job of presenting the Wonder Woman of the early comics.

However, the later seasons, set in quasi-modern/futuristic times, became very camp sci-fi affairs.

Nevertheless, none of these versions have really depicted the comics version of Wonder Woman, who can fly, is as strong and as fast as Superman, can talk to animals, has the wisdom of Athena and is a trained Amazon warrior. That means it's largely been left to animated shows and movies to depict the real Wonder Woman halfway decently.

Recently, however, in this, Wonder Woman's 70th anniversary year, NBC tried to make another TV version of Wonder Woman. For some reason, however, they got David E Kelley of Ally McBeal, Boston Legal and Harry's Law fame to do this. It's not been picked up for series, so will probably never get onto TV (just like that very first Wonder Woman pilot), but just for the sake of completeness and curiosity, I've watched it and, well, it's exactly what you think it would be like: never has a superhero worried so much about the law, jurisdiction, search warrants and the difficulties of her love life, as well as the pressures of running a company and being a woman in today's world.

So it would be tempting, at first, to suggest that David E Kelley hasn't gone anywhere near the source material, beyond having maybe watched a couple of adverts for the TV series once upon a time. We have a Wonder Woman who's a bit strong and fast, she has a lasso, she's an Amazon warrior, she has an alternative identity, Diana Prince, and there's a guy called Steve Trevor who hangs about.

But there's no Greek gods, no Paradise Island, no mission to teach the world its errors, no super-powers beyond great strength and no invisible plane. And although it might be called the Lasso of Truth - it is the literal, unbreakable embodiment of truth in the comics and can look into your soul - the most it can do is lasso people, so Wonder Woman actually has to torture criminals to get information out of them.

Instead, we have Wonder Woman running a corporation that sells Wonder Woman merchandise to fund her crime-fighting activities - her costume is deliberately "action figuresque" to boost sales here, rather than as a tribute to her adopted homeland or Steve Trevor's mother, who saved some Amazons' lives during WW2. Because she fights crime. That's what she does. No higher mission for this Wonder Woman.

Wonder Woman with her action figure

This Wonder Woman's biggest problem is that evil corporate boss Liz Hurley is making terrible drugs that kill people, while also doing research on humans to create super soldiers that could possibly be as strong as Wonder Woman herself. And she must expose Hurley's evil schemes, first by accusing her without evidence, and then by breaking into her company's HQ and killing lots of people.

Liz Hurley in Wonder Woman

But there are at least a few nods to the original comics. She has a friend called Etta Candy, she flies a plane, even if it's not invisible, she calls herself Diana Thermyscira (the real name of Paradise Island) and while the corporation idea is new, the comics did have the idea that Wonder Woman would sell merchandising of herself, although largely to fund good will projects to help women.

Against this backdrop, we have the constant problem of the pressures of being Wonder Woman. She has to have the "perfect ass, the perfect breasts, the perfect teeth" and never show a moment of vulnerability or make a mistake. It's not exactly sub-text, given Diana says all these things herself, but the message is clear, if a little five years ago - being a superwoman/Wonder Woman is impossible, even for Wonder Woman herself, let alone for ordinary mortals.

We also have Wonder Woman's desire to have a regular life. She lives in an apartment under the pseudonym Diana Prince with a cat, is trying to date through Facebook and moved to LA after a two-year relationship with Steve Trevor (there are hints at the backstory that she came back with him from Paradise Island). She watches soap operas with yearning, although thankfully, the scripted "dancing to Single Ladies while eating ice cream" scene never materialised in the filmed pilot.

Wonder Woman watching a soap opera

Does any of it work?
Surprisingly, on some levels it does work. The attempts to humanise Diana, who can be a little perfect in the comics, are admirable, even if they're fundamentally flawed. The Steve Trevor-Diana relationship is actually not bad if you ignore the fact that she's an Amazon princess, although given that Justin Bruening from the Knight Rider remake plays Steve Trevor, it's not well acted.

The fight scenes are surprisingly well handled, too, some of the best and indeed most brutal that superhero TV has given us yet - this is a Wonder Woman who can definitely kick arse and her golden lasso is as infinitely long and handy in a fight as it is in the comics.

Wonder Woman with lasso

Wonder Woman fight

Wonder Woman somersault

She can also deflect bullets with her bracelets.

Wonder Woman deflecting bullets

That jet she has is very nifty, too.

Wonder Woman in her jet

Wonder Woman flying her jet

But this is still a Wonder Woman robbed of her powers and dignity, who complains that the action figure versions of herself have ridiculous tits (her word). She limps after being hit by a car, although it at least has the good grace to smash on impact. She also kills people surprisingly often for an emissary of peace, something the comics Wonder Woman isn't 100% averse to but who usually tries to first find a better way of dealing with problems than throwing steel pipes into people's necks.

There's the usual Kelley mis-handling of ethnic minorities, who might as well be from Tom and Jerry cartoons for all the work put into their characters. The dialogue is painful, cliched and hackneyed. The plot is like a Chinese whispers version of the idea of a 1970s comic. And any interaction between women and men has to have Kelley's trademark take on gender relationships. Hurley and Wonder Woman even spend more time talking about how assertive Wonder Woman should be ("Oh, I heard you were so nice in person").

And then there's the legal aspect of this, something that the comics or indeed any previous version of Wonder Woman have barely touched. As well as an amazing number of cameos from actual lawyers such as Nancy Grace and Alan Dershowitz (as well as Dr Phil) and the fact that Steve Trevor is no longer an airforce test pilot but a lawyer with the Department of Justice, almost every single scene involves lengthy discussions about the legality of what Wonder Woman does. Can she speak to a prisoner in police custody? Can she enter somewhere without a warrant? Can she make accusations in public? Given that she's a diplomat from Thermyscira in the comic, you'd think diplomatic immunity could avoided all that pain, but apparently not. So every scene feels like it carries a 15-day waiting period and background check before anything exciting is allowed to happen.

Allen Dershowitz in Wonder Woman

Adrianne Palicki does almost look the part, at least, despite a plasticky costume that was going to need a lot of CGI to improve. She's fine at the physical work, a little wooden, but by no means the worst actor in the whole piece, Bruening and Hurley in a tie for that hallowed position. Cary Elwes (The Princess Bride) is Diana's corporate advisor and is fine, but clearly in a different David E Kelley show altogether. Hopefully they'll both go onto better things.

On the whole, while it does have a few things going for it, it's probably a good thing this version of Wonder Woman will never hit the airwaves. Unfortunately, it might also have been the kibosh on a proper version of Wonder Woman appearing either in movies or on TV for a few more years yet. Which is a shame.

UPDATE (2/8/11): And here's the whole thing. Watch it while you can!

UPDATE (29/3/15): And now here it is again!

Related entries

  • August 2, 2011: The full Wonder Woman (2011) pilot
    The full 2011 Wonder Woman pilot is now available online to view
  • September 22, 2011: Review: Wonder Woman #1
    A review of issue #1 of Wonder Woman
  • January 3, 2012: That Wonder Woman costume returns
    Erica Durance is wearing the Wonder Woman costume from the failed pilot in Harry's Law
  • March 23, 2012: Review: Wonder Woman #7/Justice League #6, 7
    A review of Wonder Woman #7 and Justice League #6, 7
  • September 10, 2012: Question of the week: is another go at a Wonder Woman TV series a good thing or a bad thing?
    Is a Wonder Woman TV series a good or a bad idea?
  • February 16, 2013: Review: Monday Mornings 1x1 (TNT/Fox)
    A review of the first episode of TNT's Monday Mornings
  • March 28, 2013: What did you watch this fortnight? Including It's Kevin, Plebs, GI Joe: Retaliation, Parks and Recreation, and Arrow
    What I watched in the fortnight ending 28 March 2013
  • April 1, 2013: The Adventures of Super Pup
    Possibly the worst superhero spin-off TV show ever
  • May 10, 2013: Your handy guide to true religions on TV
    Your handy guide to true religions on TV
  • May 13, 2013: Your handy guide to true religions on TV - Hellenism and Religio Romana
    All the scripted shows on Western, English-language TV that have not just featured Hellenism or Religio Romana but have actually shown them to be true in some way or other
  • September 30, 2013: Mini-review: The Crazy Ones 1x1 (CBS)
    A review of CBS's The Crazy Ones
  • May 6, 2014: Electra Woman and Dyna Girl: the 2001 version
    The 2001 reboot of Electra Woman and Dyna Girl
  • May 25, 2014: Weekly Wonder Woman: Wonder Woman #31, Batman-Superman #11, Forever Evil #7 and Justice League #30
    A round-up of the DC comics featuring Wonder Woman in the week end 24th May 2014
  • October 27, 2014: What have you been watching? Including Mulaney, Soul Mates, Jane The Virgin, Marry Me, The Affair and Forever
    Reviews of the show’s I’ve been watching in the week ending Monday 27th October 2014
  • May 29, 2015: Weekly Wonder Woman: Sensation Comics #36, Convergence: Action Comics #2, Convergence #8, Injustice: Gods Among Us #4
    A review of the DC comics featuring Wonder Woman in the week ending 29th May 2015
  • June 22, 2015: Celebrating a decade of The Medium Is Not Enough
    It’s the tenth birthday of The Medium Is Not Enough

Read other posts about:

  • jsw7533

    Plus points... great fight scene in the warehouse - good stunt work and very Wonder Woman-esque.Adrienne Palicki could have pulled this off if she'd been given something to work with.

    Really hard to understand how someone can take such an attractive and legendary character and make it as tedious as this. You really have to try hard to make this fail - but David Kelley succeeded. We dodged a bullet on this one.

  • ROFL. I think that fundamentally misunderstands the character. She's an Amazon, a princess and has god-given powers (literally). She comes from a matriarchal society that's existed for thousands of years without men. There have been no real expectations for her in terms of appearance, other than to be strong, no need to appeal to anyone. She has the wisdom of Athena, the strength of Heracles, the speed/flight of Hermes and more.

    Given all that, why, when she comes to America, given the chance of doing anything she wants and, more importantly, being charged by both the gods and the Amazons with the job of showing 'man's world' and patriarchy there's a better of way living life and of treating women, does she set up a company based around selling fashion accessories and models of dolls to girls, that commoditise her?

    It's such a paucity of imagination and essentially gives the message that even without the influence of men and patriarchy, rather than being scientists, philosophers, athletes, inventors, teachers or writers, all women are fundamentally good for, all they can ever be is pretty and that's all the power and strength they have.

    Sure, she could be the CEO of a company that sells action figures based on herself. But, you know, fundamentally, with the beauty of Aphrodite, she could just be a supermodel or do porn, so why not do that hey? Much easier than having to decide pressing issues like how big the breasts on her action figures should be.

  • Afrodiva

    LOL her building a brand around herself is a problem? I think it's genius! Beautiful women are already commoditized, the smart one becomes a successful business woman off it AND uses that wealth to do good. I love the concept, and as a business owner I don't see why she couldn't do it w/o family ties, you hire people with expertise to do that. #amazonpower

  • I don't think WW being a CEO is necessarily unbelievable - after all, in the comics, she's at various points ruled whole kingdoms/queendoms, a worldwide foundation, been a UN ambassador and more. Tony Stark's the son of a CEO so perhaps has more insight into running a company than WW, who grew up on an apparently moneyless tropical island, but there's no reason she couldn't become a CEO and learn on the job.

    The problem is more that in the pilot, she's the CEO of a company dedicated to selling fashionwear and action figures based on her and her costume, and most of her business meetings apparently revolve around discussing how big her breasts are.

  • Afrodiva

    Hmm IDK I found it entertaining. True I'm not a purist, but I loved WW as a child and don't have an issue reinventing her for present day. Why is her being a CEO unbelievable, but Tony Starks not? I wish they had run with this!

  • sassy K

    Wonder Woman is one of my favorite childhood tv shows and favorite superheroes. This version wasnt terrible but it could have been better. Wonder Woman doesnt kill. Wonder Womans identity was always secret, having her run a corporation where everyone knows that she is Wonder Woman was totally unbelivable. They should get new writers who are more familiar with the tv series and the comic books. Revisit it with a more believable format. Have her be the daughter of the original and bring Lynda back as the Amazon Queen. Dont try to remake Lynda, that is a mistake. No one can be her.

  • Thanks for dropping by. I agree with you about The New Adventures of Wonder Woman (in fact, I said as much in the piece: "The first season, set as the original comic was during World War 2, wasn't bad and did a reasonably good job of presenting the Wonder Woman of the early comics"

    As for the Cathy Lee Gifford movie, there might have been an overlap in production and development, I grant you, but WW gets de-powered in 1968 and re-powered in 1973 in the comics and the TV movie was in 1974, so it was, if anything, reflecting an era that had just gone by. But no white catsuit!

    As for Wonder Woman's superpowers, the strength, speed, wisdom, etc were there from pretty much the beginning although they didn't become god-given rather than simply Amazonian until a few years into the comic. Flight didn't turn up until the 80s, though, you're right.

    And for the pilot, I agree - it has good points and bad points, and I hope I showed that. I think there are a lot more bad points than good points though.

  • 7thCylon

    [I stand chastened and corrected, Rob] To the author, your comment about The New Adventures of Wonder Woman & Cathy Lee Crosby Movie "Nevertheless, none of these versions have really depicted the comics version of Wonder Woman, who can fly, is as strong and as fast as Superman, can talk to animals, has the wisdom of Athena and is a trained Amazon warrior. That means it's largely been left to animated shows and movies to depict the real Wonder Woman halfway decently." Just a little info for you, back in the 70's. The New Adventures of Wonder Woman was pretty close to showing what was going on with her in her early comics and the comics of the 70's. The Cathy Lee Crosby WW ( Water board me for even saying this as dreadful as it was to watch) kind of hit upon that era back then when DC underpowered WW. So all in all, they were based on the WW of their era. All the Bells & whistles WW did not come around until the 80s I believe. Just a FYI. Now back to this mess of a Pilot. It has its points both good and bad. Its a Pilot, and just that. Lets be great full for small Wonders on this front

  • "Wasting more money, surely. How much was already wasted on this thing?"

    Hard to say. Could be lots. Fringe's pilot was $12-15m, but that was by the point of completion. This pilot wouldn't have gone anywhere near that amount, I don't think, but it was quite expensive for quite a number of reasons - one of the problems that stopped a Wonder Woman show from happening for so long was the cost of licensing the character, but there was the cast cost, some of the expensive CGI was done (the plane for example) all the shooting was done. It looks quite cheap at times, but it's got to have cost a good few million dollars at least.

  • SK

    Wasting more money, surely. How much was already wasted on this thing?

blog comments powered by Disqus

Allowable comments

You can leave just about any kind of comment you like. You can argue, suggest I am (or anyone else is) wrong, leaving general messages of love – anything. However, you absolutely can't leave messages that attack other commenters (or me), are simple variations of "your review sucks" or that are misogynistic, racist, homophobic, etc: your comment will either be edited or deleted and you'll be barred from leaving any further comments. We want to keep it civil here.

Featured Articles

Baron Noir

Brexit and the Labour leadership contest… but in French