In the US: Fridays, 9pm et/pt, CBS
What do women want? It's a despairing thought asked by male TV executives all the time, in the hope of getting some female viewers for their networks. Sometimes they'll look at the chick lit section of their local Barnes and Noble and go, "Oh. That's what women want." Other times, they'll look at other female oriented TV programmes and copycommission appropriately.
Sometimes, though, they'll look overseas, usually to Britain and sometimes to Canada. But for The Ex List, they looked even further afield: Israel.
The Ex-List's premise is dumbness in a glass: 33-year-old San Diego flower shop owner, Bella Bloom (seriously), takes her sister's hen night party to a psychic and gets told she has a year to marry or she'll die alone. After a series of other predictions come true, she becomes convinced the psychic is telling the truth. Thing is, she's destined to marry someone she's already dated, so she puts together a list of all her exes, and decides to try them out again, one at a time, to see which was really Mr Right.
So roll up, roll up for the oddball man vetting service.
The Ex-List is surprisingly not bad. On the one hand, the mind rebels at the ridiculous premise of the whole show. But there have been stupider starting points for great shows so let's not get too tied up in that. Then there's the fact that every single facet of the show, from the casting to the dialogue to the plots to the wardrobe to the set design might as well have "THIS IS FOR YOU. YOU ARE A GIRL. YOU MUST WATCH THIS. IT'S BIOLOGY. WE THINK." written all over it. A surfer girl who owns a flower shop and rides a twee bike? I don't think so.
Then there's the central character, Bella, who just isn't that interesting. She's more interesting by the end of the episode than she appears to be at first, but ultimately, it's hard to root for someone who is by far the dullest character in the whole show. To a certain extent, I think it's a combination of miscasting, wardrobe and design, since on paper, the character seems far more interesting. Instead, the ostensible live wire appears to have been earthed.
But those problems aside, there are some good aspects to the show. All the supporting and incidental characters are interesting, even the male ones. The men aren't complete a-holes, which is something to be thankful for, and the script did make numerous turns and twists that were pretty unexpected - you think it's going one way, and it goes somewhere completely different. At the very least, you have to give kudos to a writer that somehow manages to introduce a mirkin into one of the sub-plots.
The laughs were a little few and far between, but there were laughs and this is just episode one. Worryingly, the show's main (sole?) female exec-producer has already departed and she wrote the script so it might well be that the good qualities will evaporate in later episodes. But if the original Israeli scripts are good, maybe that won't be such an issue.
Could be promising, but sufficiently flawed that I'm not holding out too much hope.
Here's a promo that introduces the whole show, you lucky people.
- October 20, 2008: Third-episode verdict: The Ex-List
A review of The Ex-List based on the first three episodes
- February 8, 2010: Third-episode verdict: Life Unexpected
A review of the first three episodes of The CW's Life Unexpected
- April 14, 2010: Season finale: Life Unexpected
A review of the first season of Life Unexpected
- May 18, 2010: Clips and details of Fox's new shows for Fall 2010
What new shows do Fox have for Fall 2010? Details and videos.
- February 10, 2011: Review: Traffic Light 1x1
A review of the first episode of Fox's Traffic Light, starring Kris Marshall but not Alex Breckenridge any more
- March 3, 2011: How pilot casting sometimes works: Alex Breckenridge demonstrates
Alex Breckenridge gets cast in a pilot
- October 4, 2011: Review: Homeland 1x1
A review of the first episode of Showtime/Channel 4's Homeland, starring Claire Danes, Damian Lewis and Mandy Patinkin
- June 15, 2015: Yes, American TV has improved since the 1990s
Has American TV improved since 1990s? I think it has