Categorised | US TV reviews

Preview: Heroes

Posted on July 20, 2006 | Post a comment | Bookmark and Share


In the US: Mondays 9/8c, NBC. Starts September 25, 2006
In the UK: Not yet acquired, although Channel 4 is most likely to pick it up

After last year's sci-fi 'dump', where virtually every new drama commissioned by the US networks - Invasion, Surface, Threshold, etc - had an SF theme, it's interesting to note that NBC's Heroes is more or less the only new SF show this time round. Even then, it qualifies more as fantasy than SF, since it follows a group of ordinary super-heroes - if there is such a thing - rather than aliens or some other sci-fi staple. It's not very original and clearly owes The 4400 a debt or two, but it's actually pretty good.

The plot
Essentially, Heroes is an emergence story (or will be for its first season). A group of regular, ordinary people, none of whom know each other, slowly become aware that they're not as ordinary as they first thought:

  • An artist discovers his paintings are starting to predict the future;
  • a high-school cheerleader realises that she's almost indestructible, with broken bones and wounds healing in seconds;
  • a single mum (Ali Larter from Legally Blonde, Final Destination, etc) who owes money to the mob finds out the hard way that her reflection has a dangerous mind of its own;
  • a police officer (Greg Grunberg from Alias) can hear the thoughts of others;
  • a Japanese office worker (Masi Oka from Scrubs) is able to warp space and time to move objects including himself with just the power of his mind; and
  • one of two brothers (Adrian Pasdar from Profit and Milo Ventimiglia from Gilmore Girls) will learn he can fly.

Most are unwilling to believe their own eyes, suspecting they're going mad until they face incontrovertible evidence to the contrary. Others, such as cheerleader girl and Japanese office worker, embrace their gifts, with cheerleader rescuing a man from a burning building just to see if fire can hurt her, and office worker wanting to be special and a winner for once in his life.

Unfortunately, someone's out to get them. A professor in Madras, whose father foresaw the evolution of these special powers shortly before he was mysteriously killed in New York, is threatened by a man who seems to know everything about him and his own theories. Who he is, we don't know, but it's clear he and others know more about these gifts than their owners.

More worrying is the prediction of an imminent catastrophe by one of the artist's paintings. If the various gifted individuals don't learn about each other's existence and embrace their powers, something very, very bad is going to happen.

The verdict
This is essentially the Bruce Willis film Unbreakable, but with a group of emerging super-heroes instead of just one. It's also The 4400, but with evolution (or some freak cosmic event) rather than aliens as the mysterious benefactor of super-powers. Despite the fact it's been done before, it's actually done pretty well and there are some nice touches.

For one thing, there is at least some geographic variety in the origins of these heroes. It's not just going to be an all-American world-saving team, with Sendhil Ramamurthy's Indian professor looking like he's going to be the brains of the operation who pieces everything together. Masi Oka gives a decent comedic turn as the Japanese office worker, and with Lost having shown that you can have subtitled, foreign-language dialogue during prime time, it's refreshing to note that Oka - bar the occasional borrowed word - speaks Japanese for the entire pilot.

The fact that, with the exception of the New York chapter of the league of new superheroes, none of the other characters have met yet is also an interesting facet, with few of the characters' individual stories yet entwined with the others'.

If I had any major criticism, it would be that the pilot was perhaps just a little too languorous in its pacing. There's going to be a risk, as with Unbreakable, that Heroes will spend just too long trying to be normal and realistic in an effort to highlight the problems one must face in accepting that you can teleport, etc. The result will inevitably be a load of tedious clock-watching, wondering when we're going to see some super-powers or plot development. The pilot just steered clear of that, but it came very close.

Still, it's all directed very nicely, with moody lighting. There are no real stand-outs yet in acting terms (sorry, guys. Ali Larter's just too hot for me to be able to tell if she can act or not. I think she's great, but I suspect my opinion is tinted somewhat), although there are no bum notes.

Intriguingly, unless I blinked and missed him, Greg Grunberg didn't actually show up in the pilot so I can't really rate how he does. Since often pilots get re-engineered before final broadcast (cf Tru Calling, which lost an entire character between screener and airing, and The Loop, which gained a new character and recast another before it made series), Grunberg could well be in the final version that airs or just appear in the second episode.

The dialogue's not great and there are few clichés in terms of characterisation, but this is a series about super-heroes so we shouldn't be too surprised by that. What's more surprising is that bar these few niggles of mine, I think the show was actually pretty good. One to watch, I think, and potentially one that will last a while, providing they can avoid meandering and add in some good plot developments as the series runs.

You can find out more, watch trailers, etc at the official site.

Postscript: You may have noticed that I've not actually commented on any of the soundtracks to these screeners. The problem is screeners almost always carry "placeholder" music, just like film trailers. The vast majority of the dramatic screeners I've watched have been using music from The Bourne Identity, while Heroes uses music recycled from Batman Begins. Hidden Palms just filled every scene with one-minute snatches of Coldplay, Jem and other middle-of-the-road youth musicians. So I suspect we're going to have to wait for the series to air before we know for sure what they'll sound like.

Related entries

  • July 24, 2006: NBC announces fall schedule
    The dates of NBC's fall schedule are now avaiiable. It all kicks off on September 18th. Noteably, Aaron Sorkin's Studio 60 On The Sunset Strip will appear on September 18th. As mentioned previously, Heroes joins the Monday night line-up...
  • July 27, 2006: The limits of a screener
    In my duties as screener reviewer, I made my way through Heroes. I remarked at the the time that it was odd that Greg Grunberg wasn't in the pilot. Turns out, they edited the pilot down to an hour...
  • October 11, 2006: Third-episode verdict: Heroes
    My third-episode verdict on Heroes.
  • July 14, 2009: Ashley Crow: from and PROBE
    When Heroes first came out, I did the usual thing of checking the cast list to see if there was anyone I knew whom I liked on the list. "Masi Oka? Okay, he's in Scrubs. Ali Larter? Ooh, I...
  • September 25, 2015: Review: Heroes Reborn 1x1 (US: NBC)
    A review of the first two episodes of Heroes: Reborn

Read other posts about: ,

Allowable comments

You can leave just about any kind of comment you like. You can argue, suggest I am (or anyone else is) wrong, leaving general messages of love – anything. However, you absolutely can't leave messages that attack other commenters (or me), are simple variations of "your review sucks" or that are misogynistic, racist, homophobic, etc: your comment will either be edited or deleted and you'll be barred from leaving any further comments. We want to keep it civil here.


You can hide a spoiler by putting <spoiler> before it and </spoiler> after it. Hover over a spoiler to reveal it!

Featured Articles

Marvel's Iron Fist

Season two of Daredevil but done right