Categorised | TV reviews

Tags |

Review: Kyle XY 1x1

Posted on June 29, 2006 | Post a comment | Bookmark and Share


Normally, there's nothing quite like the word 'family' (as in 'a family show') to inspire fear in the heart of any seasoned TV watcher. In general, 'family' equates to inoffensive, moralising, bland and unchallenging. When you have a whole network with 'family' in the title – as in ABC Family – you can pretty much write off its entire output as the visual equivalent of Saga magazine. Once in a while though, a programme comes along to buck the trend. Not much, but a little.

Kyle with no belly buttonKyle is a strange teenager. He wakes up naked in a wood one day with no memory of anything. And I mean anything: no language, no understanding of how to process sensory inputs, no idea of what a toilet is... He also appears at first to have little by way of emotion, regarding everything with the same neutral curious expression. One last thing: he also had no belly button.

In no time at all and faster than you can say “streaker”, he's locked away in a juvenile detention facility where he gets entrusted into the care of a social worker experienced in the ways of 'special' children. She takes him home to meet the rest of her pleasing nuclear family who are generally freaked out by him.

They get even more freaked out when he manages to learn rudimentary English in a day and memorise machine representations of JPEG images with just a glance. A quick scan of his brain down the local hospital reveals its pretty much chugging along at 100% capacity, instead of the 9% we tend to use.

Soon Kyle is endearing himself to the other family members by clearing up their rooms, rescuing them from thuggish police with improvised aikido-esque martial arts and helping them repair computers.

Kyle is clearly not John Doe. ClearlyKyle XY proves the belief of Kevin McLory and co that if you don't do something right the first time, there's no shame in trying again. In this case, the producers clearly believed that John Doe was a fine show, cancelled before its time, and it deserves a second chance.

The central driving interest of John Doe was the mystery of who he was. Kyle XY wisely continues with that plan and develops on it. While John Doe was clearly making it up as it went along, Kyle XY seems to have a strategy from the outset. ABC has built up an extensive web site for the series, which is replete with things like “Clue Trackers” and so on. The aim is for the audience to keep a very close eye out for clues during episodes: why does Kyle have no belly button? Is the XY of the title a reference to chromosomes and therefore of some genetic experiment? Is his constant talk of the “human species” in voice-over a suggestion he's an alien or part of a new engineered species? Is his lack of strong emotion a suggestion that he's an android? Who is the mysterious girl mentioned on television as having been washed ashore with no memories – Jane XX?

And if they're watching out for clues, they're watching the television.

So far, it all seems moderately amiable and intriguing. Matt Dallas gives an intentionally wooden yet paradoxically charismatic performance as Kyle. If aliens, government conspiracies and robots can be avoided, the central mystery seems like a good one, although how long it can be strung out for remains to be seen. The supporting cast are all shiny attractive people and the guest cast is pretty much the same guest cast you'll find in any US show shot in Canada (Stargate fans will spot both Teryl Rothery and Kevin Durand, among others). Moralising has so far been non-existent, except in the liberal “live and let live, let's all love one another” way of life demonstrated by the nuclear family. There's also promise in the next episode of a menacing threat for Kyle, which should prevent it slowly turning into autistic Touched by an Angel all the same.

At this stage, it could still all go pear-shaped, but I'll be tuning in, just to see if it doesn't. Shows like Kyle XY and Doctor Who that are aimed at families yet don't totally suck need our support, after all, and are actually pretty fun to watch, even if you're an adult.

If you'd like to watch more, there's an alternative trailer available on YouTube: it's just below and gives you most of the lowdown you'll need.

Related entries

  • July 12, 2006: Three-episode report on Kyle XY
    As is tradition round here, once they've reached the third-episode stage, I report back again on shows whose first episodes didn't totally suck. Kyle XY showed quite some promise, so I've stuck with it and here's how it's going....
  • September 5, 2006: Airing dates for US shows, both in the US and over here
    Kyle XY is likely to be picked up in the UK by the Disney Channel.
  • January 16, 2009: Review: Kyle XY 3x1
    A review of the first episode of the third season of ABC Family's Kyle XY
  • January 23, 2012: Review: The LA Complex (CTV/MuchMusic/The CW) 1x1-1x2
    A review of the first two episodes of CTV/MuchMusic's The LA Complex
  • January 9, 2017: What have you been watching? Including Beyond, Sherlock, and Man Seeking Woman
    The TV I watched in the week ending Monday 9th January 2017

Read other posts about:

Allowable comments

You can leave just about any kind of comment you like. You can argue, suggest I am (or anyone else is) wrong, leaving general messages of love – anything. However, you absolutely can't leave messages that attack other commenters (or me), are simple variations of "your review sucks" or that are misogynistic, racist, homophobic, etc: your comment will either be edited or deleted and you'll be barred from leaving any further comments. We want to keep it civil here.


You can hide a spoiler by putting <spoiler> before it and </spoiler> after it. Hover over a spoiler to reveal it!

Featured Articles

Twin Peaks

Lynch at his best in years