I'm supposed to be writing a white paper on the Web 2.0 conference I went to in Edinburgh last Monday. So naturally, because I am the King of Procrastination, I'm writing about Saturday's episode of Doctor Who.
On the whole, I'd say not bad. The 50s tele stuff made me all nostalgic for a decade I never lived through, which was quite impressive. The face-sucking was done nicely.
On the other hand, the union flag/jack debate annoyed me because Rose was just plain wrong (gasp, factual inaccuracies in Doctor Who!). The plot and the denouement had a few issues that really couldn't be fixed in post. And the general bog-standard interpretation of the 50s - great decade for wife beaters, we fought in the war for the right to be lippy, etc - began to grate. Could we avoid the moralising please?
Basically, a reasonable filler piece as has been remarked elsewhere.
One last thing. Writer Mark Gatiss is a long-time sci-fi fan, something you may have noticed if you watched Doctor Who Confidential after the episode. He has, for instance, played Gold in the Big Finish Sapphire and Steel audio plays. So I wonder where he got the idea for the face-sucking in The Idiot's Lantern. I'll give you a visual clue: here's the baddie in the fourth Sapphire and Steel TV 'assignment', as they're called. Look familiar?
He does like his homages does Gatiss.
- June 26, 2006: Doctor Who: Fear her
Ah kids. Little bastards, all of them. Give them a superpower and they'd all destroy the world in as much time as it takes to say, “I want my Happy Meal now!” It's a lesson written large and clear...
- January 7, 2010: The writers for series five of Doctor Who
The writers of series five of Doctor Who
- April 20, 2010: Review: Doctor Who 5x3 - Victory of the Daleks
A review of the Doctor Who episode Victory of the Daleks
- October 22, 2010: Review: The First Men in the Moon
A review of BBC4's adaptation of HG Well's First Men In the Moon